xkcd: House Majority
Comet Ice

The Archives What If? Book Thing Explainer How To Book xkcd.com



Comet Ice


A question from the What If? files: what would happen if we dropped a comet into the ocean to cool the Earth? The short answer is that it would make things hotter.

Falling warms things. Falling objects gain kinetic energy that converts to heat when they stop, warming rather than cooling the surroundings.

Atmospheric entry is worse. A comet entering the atmosphere would vaporize and heat the air, producing roughly 100 times more heat than it removes.

Slow lowering still fails. Even if lowered gently, the comet's released CO2 would trap heat and warm the planet for centuries.

A power idea instead. Lowering comets slowly with a crane-driven generator could supply the world's energy for a year with minimal emissions.

Not yet possible. The crane technology needed does not exist yet, but harvesting orbital energy is an intriguing long-term idea.



:: SUBMIT A QUESTION ::
Email
submit a question




© xkcd by Randall Munroe. Last updated 1998.

>> Site Navigation <<
xkcd: House Majority  |  About xkcd  |  [ Comet Ice ]  |  Comic Archive  |  Books by Randall Munroe  |  How To: The Book

⚠ AI Parody · Report